Looking for Collector Car Insurance?
A classic, antique or collector vehicle is not valued the way a daily driver is, and insuring it on a standard auto policy usually means accepting depreciated value on a car that has been appreciating. Redmon Insurance Agency writes collector car coverage for owners across Collinsville, Edwardsville and the Illinois Metro East.
Agreed value is the whole point
Standard auto policies settle at actual cash value — what the car is worth at the moment of loss, after depreciation. Collector policies are written on an agreed value basis: you and the insurer agree the figure up front, document it, and that is what is paid on a total loss, with no depreciation argument afterwards. For a restored or appreciating vehicle this is the difference between being made whole and being paid book value for something that has not followed the book in decades.
What collector car insurance covers
- Agreed value on the vehicle, set with you rather than imposed at claim time.
- Liability, collision and comprehensive as you would expect, but rated for limited recreational use rather than commuting.
- Spare parts and tools — often a meaningful sum for owners who stockpile hard-to-find components.
- Restoration coverage — cover that rises in step with the value you are adding during a build, rather than sitting at the value of a shell.
- Trip interruption and towing with flatbed towing, which matters for a vehicle you do not want on a hook.
- Attendance at shows and club events, including transit to and from them.
What carriers expect in return
Collector rates are lower because use is limited, so insurers set conditions: secure enclosed storage, a clean driving record, another vehicle for daily use, and usually a mileage or use restriction — typically pleasure driving, club events and shows rather than commuting or errands. Some carriers cap annual mileage, others ask only that it is not a daily driver. If your use does not fit, say so rather than discover it at claim time.
Collector car insurance FAQs
What is the difference between agreed value and stated value?
Agreed value is settled in advance and paid in full on a total loss. Stated value typically lets the insurer pay the lesser of the stated figure or actual cash value, which can leave you short. Check which basis a quote is actually offering.
Does my car have to be a certain age?
It varies by carrier. Many write vehicles from around 20 to 25 years old, but modern exotics, restored trucks and in-progress restorations are often eligible too. Being independent helps here because appetite differs between carriers.
Can I drive it to work occasionally?
Usually not under a collector policy. Most require that it is not used for commuting or daily errands. If you want occasional flexible use, tell us and we will look for a carrier whose terms allow it.
How do I document the value?
Photographs, receipts, a restoration record and in some cases an appraisal. Keeping this current matters, because agreed value is only as good as the figure you set and review.
Get a collector car quote
Call our Collinsville office at (618) 344-0381 or Edwardsville office at (618) 659-0381, or start on our quotes page. We represent 13 carriers including specialist collector markets. Related cover: auto, motorcycle, high net worth and personal umbrella.